Place an Order

Pickup only in Youngstown, Ohio. Pick your cookies and a pickup date, and Amy will confirm your order by email.

Pick your cookies

Classic Chocolate Chip
Crisp edges, a soft middle, and plenty of chocolate chips.
Dozen $30
0
Half dozen $17
0
Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies
Iced sugar cookies decorated to match your party, holiday, or theme.
Dozen $42
0
Peanut Butter
Soft and chewy, pressed with the classic crosshatch.
Dozen $30
0
Half dozen $17
0
Snickerdoodle
Rolled in cinnamon sugar and baked until just set.
Dozen $30
0
Half dozen $17
0
Assorted Dozen
Can't pick just one? Choose up to 3 flavors in one box.
Dozen $34
0
Seasonal Special
A flavor that changes with the season. Ask what's baking now.
Dozen $36
0
Half dozen $20
0

Notes or special requests (optional)

Flavor picks for an assorted dozen, decorating ideas, allergies, or anything else.

Choose a pickup date

Pickup date

We need 3 days' notice, so the earliest pickup date is Friday, October 16, 2026.

Your details

Name

Amy will confirm your order at this address.

Phone (optional)

For texts about your order.

Enter a phone number above to opt in to texts.

By checking this box, I consent to receive transactional text messages from Just More Cookies related to my order, such as order confirmations and pickup reminders, among others. Message frequency may vary. Message & data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help or STOP to opt out.

See our Privacy policy (opens in a new tab) and Terms of service (opens in a new tab).

By checking this box, I consent to receive marketing and promotional text messages from Just More Cookies, including new flavors, seasonal menus, and specials, among others. Message frequency may vary. Message & data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help or STOP to opt out.

See our Privacy policy (opens in a new tab) and Terms of service (opens in a new tab).

Total$0

Online payment isn't set up yet, so you won't be charged.

Loading the order form…

Place an Order

Pick your cookies

Classic Chocolate Chip

Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies

Peanut Butter

Snickerdoodle

Assorted Dozen

Seasonal Special

Choose a pickup date

Your details

Pick your cookies

Classic Chocolate Chip

Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies

Peanut Butter

Snickerdoodle

Assorted Dozen

Seasonal Special

Choose a pickup date

Your details