Just More Cookies

Small-batch cookies, baked to order for birthdays, showers, holidays, and just because.

Pickup only in Youngstown, Ohio.

Priced by the dozen. Some flavors also come by the half dozen.

Classic Chocolate Chip
$30 per dozen
Crisp edges, a soft middle, and plenty of chocolate chips.
Half dozen
$17
Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies
$42 per dozen
Iced sugar cookies decorated to match your party, holiday, or theme.
By the dozen only
Peanut Butter
$30 per dozen
Soft and chewy, pressed with the classic crosshatch.
Half dozen
$17
Snickerdoodle
$30 per dozen
Rolled in cinnamon sugar and baked until just set.
Half dozen
$17
Assorted Dozen
$34 per dozen
Can't pick just one? Choose up to 3 flavors in one box.
By the dozen only
Seasonal Special
$36 per dozen
A flavor that changes with the season. Ask what's baking now.
Half dozen
$20

From the kitchen

Pick your cookies
Choose from the menu by the dozen, or by the half dozen where it's offered.
Choose a pickup date
Pick a day that works for you. We need 3 days' notice, so plan a little ahead.
Confirm your order
Send your order request, and Amy will confirm it by email.

Hi, I'm Amy. Just More Cookies is my home bakery in Youngstown, Ohio, where I bake special-order cookies in small batches.

Tell me what you're celebrating, and I'll help you put together the right box for it.

Questions before you order? Email me at amy@justmorecookies.com.